The Essay’s Importance in Test-Optional Admissions

Even with standardized tests and target GPAs, college admissions have long seemed arbitrary and unpredictable. Back when we used a typewriter to fill out paper applications, we joked that the admissions folks simply tossed the files into the air and awarded the owner of the file that fell closest to their feet with admission. We knew this wasn’t true, but more than one friend considered adding scientifically placed paperclips to their pages in the hopes of creating a lucky trajectory. While applications have gone online, the system hasn’t changed much over the years.

Welcome to 2020, the year when even the most competitive colleges and universities have decided to make standardized test scores optional. This may come as a relief to students who were unable to snag a test spot during this season of cancelations and social distancing, but how will schools decide whom to admit? Applicants (and colleges for that matter) are wondering how the incoming class will be chosen. Without standardized tests, what metric will they use?

According to Rebecca Koenig in “Can Algorithms Select Students ‘Most Likely to Succeed?’” (Slate Magazine, July 2020), colleges may move away from standardized tests all together in favor of a “holistic” approach to admissions that’s less about test scores and more about the person. Koenig mentions characteristics that are difficult to quantify, such as grit, potential for learning, problem-solving skills, integrity, confidence, and the ability to learn from your mistakes. Koenig explains colleges may “look out for students who seem confident, realistic about their own weakness, and able to work toward long-range goals.”

 How do you show that you possess these qualities? I suggest that you craft an application essay that provides evidence that you possess one, or more, of these traits. The goal is to tell a story that captures your resilience, determination, ability to forgive, creativity, openness to different ways of thinking … you get the idea. The goal is to provide the admissions folks with a glimpse of what you’re like beyond your grades and illustrate to them that you have the makings of a successful college student.

 I know that’s a lot to ask from 650 words, but I know you can do it. Begin by checking out my list of essay tips on this site. For individualized assistance brainstorming and writing, plus constructive feedback and editing contact me: abby@gowriteworkshop.com.  

https://slate.com/technology/2020/07/college-admissions-algorithms-applications.html